A tale of two realities in china – risk prevention & maintenance

There are two fundamentally different approaches to risk management among water companies in China, writes Bruno Lhopiteau.

Law enforcement steps up against pollution

At the end of last year, a foreign-funded environmental firm operating in China was fined a record 50M Chinese Yuan (US$7m) for the illegal discharge of wastewater. A total of 11 of its executives were jailed.

Industrial accidents have made headlines in China in the past decade, prompting local authorities to strengthen regulations and to significantly step up law enforcement.

As a result, treatment plants were forcibly shut down after failing environmental audits, and managers jailed for gross misconduct. On top of such dire legal consequences, the impact on revenue, stock price, image, is enormous.

Investigations into wrongdoings or corruption have shown that incidents almost always stem from a lack of technical knowledge at both management and working levels. This includes decisions made without understanding their potential impact, or tasks performed without following proper procedures and methodology. This grassroots challenge is the most difficult to address.

Indeed, the comparatively late industrial development of the Chinese economy, compounded by the sheer size of the country and extremely rapid growth, has led to an acute shortage of experienced managers, engineers and skilled technicians. This is especially the case with the multi-disciplinary knowledge essential for maintenance.

Holistic versus silo approaches

Environmental firms must balance all aspects of this complex problem, especially in the context of increasing regulatory oversight and toughening market conditions. We observe two fundamentally different approaches to risk management among water companies in China.

The first I would characterize as “holistic”, often structured around a standard such as ISO 55000 or ISO 31000 that takes an integrated view of risk management, with maintenance playing a central role.

The Chinese government has been advocating digitalization since the late 1990s as a supportive tool, in order to improve industrial practices. To an outsider, this approach looks like another “Smart Water” initiative, albeit one centered on risk prevention, encompassing a multidepartment, multidisciplinary scope.

The second approach I call the “silo” approach, featuring a shopping list of improvements in IT (too often gimmicks such as facial recognition at entrance gates), staff training, legal protection (for foreign firms it often involves putting a Chinese national in the top position...), process control systems.

To the untrained eye, this approach looks again like “Smart Water” but with a telltale architecture: a central data warehouse, replicating data from a variety of separate systems (maintenance, HSE, inspections, lab, environmental reporting), is used to produce management reports.

And the winner?

As maintenance consultants, we are sensitive to the fact that companies adopting the second approach tend to undervalue maintenance. They tell us that water treatment equipment is simple, employees are not well qualified, and they want a cheaper IT system for maintenance.

They do not agree on the central, multidisciplinary, role of maintenance and totally disconnect HSE from maintenance. Furthermore, results from official investigations showing technical management as the leading cause of accidents are often disregarded.

Which approach will come out the winner? My view is that, due to a wrong diagnosis, the “silo” approach is leaving the root cause of the problem unanswered, exposing those companies and the public they serve, to risk.

The foreign wastewater firm caught in the legal case mentioned earlier belonged to this category. So did several foreign firms that divested from China in the last few years.

On the other hand, companies adopting a holistic approach to risk prevention seem to be doing well and growing their business. In any case, my advice is for companies to look deeper into their smart water initiative to address the challenge of risk prevention.

Siveco China Head Office

Unit J, 20th floor, Zao Fong Universe Building
No.1800 Zhong Shan Road (W)
Shanghai 200235 - PR China

About Siveco China

Siveco China (www.sivecochina.com), founded in 2004, is a pioneer in the development of Smart Technologies for the Operation & Maintenance of infrastructures and industrial plants, with a focus on mobile solutions "for the worker of tomorrow".

Long before the terms "smart" and "4.0" were coined, Siveco has been helping clients optimize the lifecycle of their assets and ensure regulatory compliance using IT. Based on a long experience of "maintenance with Chinese characteristics", the company has designed a unique approach combining expert maintenance consulting and technological innovation. Smart O&M solutions developed in Siveco's R&D center in Shanghai cover Asset Management, Maintenance 4.0, Risk Prevention and HSE, utilizing Mobility, IoT, BIM, AR and AI technologies.

Siveco China has over 900 customer sites all over Greater China and on the Belt & Road, including ABB, Baosteel Metal, Beijing Environment, Capital Water, Carrefour China, CEPSA, CNEEC, CNOOC, COSCO, Fushun Mining, Engie, Everbright, GE, New World Development, Saint-Gobain, Shell, Suez NWS, Yingde Gases, Zhongshan Water etc. The company boasts a growing export business, working alongside Asian EPC companies and with international clients in Southeast Asia, the Middle-East and Africa.

Siveco China has won numerous awards, most recently the prestigious Brilliant 40 Years prize by the China Electric Power Equipment Management Association, Top Ten Enterprise for Asset Informatization Service by the and the China Association of Machinery Equipment Maintenance and Renovation (CAMER) and Best Industrial Software 2017 by Control Engineering China. Previous awards include CHaINA Supply Chain Excellence Award 2013 and Engineers' Choice Awards by Plant360 in three categories in 2015.

Siveco is ISO 9001-certified by Bureau Veritas for its entire scope of business. The company is headquartered in Shanghai, where it also operates its R&D center, and has offices in Hong Kong. Siveco China is a subsidiary of Siveco Group, a European pioneer in computerized maintenance management systems (CMMS).

Siveco China publishes the "Smart Operation & Maintenance - for the worker of tomorrow" newsletter dedicated to maintenance management, bilingual English and Chinese, available to subscribers and online.

Contact

Tel (China mainland): 4006 300 213
Tel (overseas): +86 21 64403226
E-mail : info@sivecochina.com

This release was published on openPR.